I’ve always liked the idea that consuming raw, local honey could reduce seasonal allergies.
The concept is elegant in its simplicity: Bees transfer local pollen into the honey, providing protection to individuals taking it. But is there any evidence to support the theory?
In Western medicine, the practice of immunotherapy exposes a person to an allergen with the expectation that the body will become desensitized to it over time. Perhaps taking local honey could work the same way.
One 2002 study examined the difference in reduction of seasonal allergy symptoms by subjects in three separate groups. The first group was given locally collected, unpasteurized, unfiltered honey; the second, nationally collected, filtered and pasteurized honey; and the third, corn syrup with synthetic honey flavoring. The conclusion: Neither honey group fared better than the placebo group.
But this may not tell the entire story. Immunotherapy can take years to yield results – a patient of mine received allergy shots from age 5 to 16. Even then, therapy does not always provide protection. While honey’s allergy-modifying benefits also may take time to reveal themselves, experts claim that this misses the point. The kinds of pollens that are the greatest cause of allergies are smaller, windblown pollens not typically found in honey.
While raw honey does contain small amounts of pollen, honey is produced by honey bees from the nectar of plants, not pollen. In other words, pollen occurs only incidentally in honey. According to Lutz Elflein, Ph.D., a honey analysis expert with an international food laboratory, the amount of pollen in honey is miniscule according to the National Honey Board.
Enzymes and flavor
Local, unpasteurized honey retains small amounts of enzymes that may give the honey added value – possibly making it easier to digest. Color and flavor are also well-maintained, with each variety imparting unique flavor profiles based on the nectar harvested by the bees. While there are concerns about unfiltered or “unprocessed” honey containing bee parts, fungus and even mold, Todd Parsons from State Street Honey assured me that this is not the case.
“No honey is ‘unprocessed’ or it would still be in the honeycomb,” he said. “Everyone has to extract it somehow. Mine is a coarse strain using minimal heat (as heat starts to alter the color and flavor of honey). I doubt there is any venom in the honey. You’d have to be crushing bees for that to happen. Fungus will happen if the honey is harvested too early, and that is a bad beekeeper’s fault.”
8 foods to eliminate
When I have a serious question about nutrition, I turn to Craig Lane of Health Alkemy in Santa Cruz. Regarding allergies, he advocates for addressing one’s diet.
“It has always been obvious in clinical practice that when basic food allergies are corrected, environmental sensitivities vanish,” he said. “For example, by simply taking a person off a basic food allergy like milk or wheat, oftentimes there will no longer be an environmental sensitivity to cats or dogs. The basic four food allergies are wheat, milk, corn and soy (followed by beef, tomato, peanut and chocolate). The hypo-antigenic diet consists of eliminating these eight foods.”
Commercial honey: What’s missing?
The goal of one study was to find out the degree to which the minerals, antioxidants and enzymes change after honey is sent through an industrial processing system. In this experiment, 11 tests were run across 15 different samples of honey, with the author equivocating “neither raw nor processed honey is superior to the other in every way.”
“Although honey experiences significant reductions in some enzyme levels, it is not always the case for all enzymes,” the researcher said. “Furthermore, in some cases, levels of minerals and antioxidants increased, likely due to the effects of averaging the samples after processing.”
While data don’t support the use of raw honey as an allergy treatment, it has other benefits. Raw, local honey is a good choice for people who prefer to source their foods locally, want higher levels of minerals and enzymes and prefer the texture or flavor that local honey has to offer.
From a natural health perspective, it’s reasonable to assume that you want the highest nutritional value from the food you eat. It’s also ideal if the food you eat is grown and delivered to the consumer in a sustainable way.
If local honey is available to you, why not support your local beekeeper and all the good bees required for the delicate ecosystem in which we live?
Ted Ray is a licensed acupuncturist and herbalist in private practice in Mountain View. For more information, call 564-9002 or visit peninsulaacupunture.com.